Issue - meetings

Councillor J. Boughtflower

To consider the Motion agreed by Council on 10 December 2020 that:

1.    The Cabinet should consider whether any proposed development of Staines Town Centre by Spelthorne Borough Council should be kept on hold until the Staines Development Framework has been adopted;

2.    The Cabinet should consider whether developers of major applications proposed in the Staines Town Centre should be requested to defer their applications until the Staines Development Framework is adopted.

This item contains an exempt appendix.  

Reason for exemption

Appendix 4 contains exempt information within the meaning of Part 1 of Schedule 12A to the Local Government Act 1972, as amended by the Local Government (Access to Information) Act 1985 and by the Local Government (Access to information) (Variation) Order 2006 Paragraph 3 – Information relating to the financial or business affairs of any particular person (including the authority holding that information) and in all the circumstances of the case, the public interest in maintaining the exemption outweighs the public interest in disclosing the information.

The appendix sets out all the impacts which will arise if the moratorium is agreed for all the Councils development sites. Individual costs of developments will be identified and therefore needs to be confidential.

On 10 December 2020 Council agreed a Motion that Cabinet

consider a Moratorium on development in Staines-upon-Thames.

Cabinet was asked to make a decision on:

1.    Whether any proposed development of Staines Town Centre by Spelthorne Borough Council should be kept on hold until the Staines Development Framework has been adopted; and

2.    Whether Developers of Major applications proposed in the Staines Town Centre should be requested to defer their applications until the Staines Development Framework is adopted.

Cabinet considered a report which set out the background and reason for the Motion and provided a detailed analysis of the severe implications the moratorium would have if agreed.

Cabinet noted that the Council had no power to direct Developers to defer their applications and that the Council had already written to some and had received negative responses.

Cabinet discussed the report and expressed concern that a Moratorium on development in Staines-upon-Thames would have a severe impact on the Council’s revenue budget and delivery of much needed affordable housing.

Cabinet agreed that it was important that the Council listen to the views of all residents to ensure the right balance was struck between delivering affordable housing and meeting the needs of the wider community. This would be achieved through an Issues and Options consultation exercise.

Cabinet expressed the view that the Council needed to ensure that decisions were made in an open and transparent way with members having oversight of development projects at all key stages, through a cross-party sub-committee of the proposed Policy and Resources Committee as agreed at Extraordinary Council held on 21 January.

Cabinet agreed that they would like the assets team to critically review the viability of all development projects in Staines-upon-Thames to see if there was scope to amend any of the schemes whilst ensuring they remain financially viable.

Alternative options considered and rejected by Cabinet:

• To put on hold proposed Council developments of Staines Town Centre until the Staines Development Framework has been adopted.

• To proceed, without delay, with proposed Council developments of Staines Town Centre.

Resolved: That a Moratorium on Council schemes in Staines-Upon-Thames should take place until such time as three things take place, with the intention that these will be completed prior to the Annual Council meeting in May 2021;

1.    That the Strategic Planning team undertake an Issues and Options consultation exercise for the Staines Development Framework.

2.    That a sub-committee, which was agreed at Extraordinary Council on 21 January 2021, is included in the recommendations of the Committee System Working Group to be reported to Extraordinary Council, currently scheduled for 25 March 2021.

3.    That the viability of all the developments are reviewed by the assets team.

Reasons for Decision:

The Council will have the opportunity to pause, reflect, realign, and listen to residents’ views without the severe consequences a two-year delay would bring.

The Council will reach its decisions with more transparency and accountability and seek to achieve balance between the Borough’s housing need and the wider wishes of  ...  view the full minutes text for item 22

Councillor J. Boughtflower

To consider the Motion agreed by Council on 10 December 2020 that:

1.    The Cabinet should consider whether any proposed development of Staines Town Centre by Spelthorne Borough Council should be kept on hold until the Staines Development Framework has been adopted;

2.    The Cabinet should consider whether developers of major applications proposed in the Staines Town Centre should be requested to defer their applications until the Staines Development Framework is adopted; and

3.    The Staines Development Framework needs significant consultation with the community of Spelthorne and a public consultation will be held to review the proposed Staines Development Framework prior to formal adoption.